no idea if this has been done already, but here goes:

1. architecture in helsinki - it'5! (64 plays)
2. spoon - the figures of art (63)
3. sufjan stevens - come on! feel the illinoise... (62)
4. the decemberists - we both go down together (55)
5. andrew bird - skin is, my (53)

how i've listened to that AiH track so many times without exploding is questionable.