So its been a few months. Things have changed. I guess this is the "real" list as it shows long term pwnability.
Heres my new top 5.

1. Subtle - for hero for fool
Really, every time i listen to this it gets better. I still get urges to listen to it every couple of weeks, and then have to listen to it about 5-10 times. Amazing lyrics and scope.
2. Joanna newsome - Ys
Nothing I can say about this that hasnt already been said, apart from when I first got it I listened to it 1 million billion times, havnt listened much since though.
3. Venetian snares - cavalcade of glee and dadaist happy hardcore pompoms
Didnt buy this till after 2k6. Its amazing. Really amazing.
4. Jeremy warmsley - art of fiction
Really amazing songwriting and that. Havnt listened to it a lot since though. Shall listen again soon.
5. Return to cookie mountain - TVOTR
Still amazing songs, but havnt listened to it as much since i first got it.